Making a strawberry margarita is not half as difficult as you might think, and this one is made even easier with the help of Powell & Mahoney’s margarita mix.
Are you still with me? I did say the “M” word (mixer). I know, I know, I thought the same thing too; why would I replace my fragrant, fresh-squeezed lime juice with a high fructose corn syrup gut bomb?
Slow your roll, this stuff is not, I repeat, not the margarita mix of your college days. The Powell & Mahoney Margarita Mix is handcrafted with all natural ingredients and cane sugar, and is the perfect sweet to sour ratio that I’ll admit, I like to drink with the added fizz of a little Topo Chico on any given afternoon when tequila wouldn’t exactly be appropriate.
I came up with the idea for this Strawberry Pink Peppercorn Margarita when the kids and I were out on a hike a few weeks back and came upon a peppercorn tree hanging heavy with just ripening pink peppercorns. I’m not a huge forager (let’s just say, I’m not always right) but the fragrance of peppercorns is undeniable and these were especially well…peppery. I picked a green one off the tree, cut into it with my thumbnail and held it up to my nose. A flood of black spice filled the air and I quickly filled my pockets with as many as they would hold.
For those of you not wanting to wander around in the semi-arid desert mountains looking for a peppercorn tree, store-bought pink peppercorns will work just as well and you can use them for all kinds of other cooking adventures too—a grilled steak perhaps?
I love a crushed strawberry margarita so much this time of year when the strawberries are flushed red all the way through and bursting at the seams with juice. All you need to do is pull the stems from a few and crush them in the bottom of your mixer with a muddler or back of a wooden spoon. In this case you’d add the peppercorns too, then shake it all up with tequila and the mixer. Simple as that!

Strawberry Pink Peppercorn Margarita
A strawberry pink peppercorn margarita hits all the notes of a perfect cocktail, a little sweet, a little sour, a tad bit spicy, and full of tequila!
Ingredients
- Kosher Salt - for glass
- 6 Whole Pink Peppercorns
- 3 Strawberries, stemmed, plus more for garnish
- 2 ounces Blanco Tequila
- 2 ounces Powell & Mahoney Classic Margarita Mix
Instructions
- Cover a small plate with kosher salt. Wet the rim of a margarita or rocks glass and dip it in the salt.
- Place peppercorns and 2 strawberries in a cocktail shaker and crush together with a muddler or the handle of a wooden spoon until the strawberries are almost a puree and the peppercorns are broken into small pieces.
- Add crushed ice, P&M Classic Margarita, and tequila to the shaker. Cover and shake vigorously until the outside is beaded in sweat.
- Pour into the prepared glass, garnish with a strawberry half and enjoy!
Notes
*Note: To make a pitcher: Combine 15 peppercorns and a pint of strawberries in a blender and pulse until well broken up but not smooth. Pour into a pitcher, add 2 cups margarita mix, 2 cups of tequila, and stir well to combine. Fill with ice and serve.
One More Thing
Did you love this post? I want to know! Leave me a comment and snap a photo for Instagram. Tag @holajalapeno so I can see your beautiful creation! Your feedback is super important to me. If you run into trouble shoot me a message on Instagram and I’ll walk you through it.
Also, don’t forget to sign up for my weekly newsletter, lots of good stuff there too!
This margarita is gorgeous and so delicious! The addition of the pink peppercorns is brilliant! Thank you for hosting such a fun event!
Thank you so much Annie! I’ve had so much fun discovering your site. Thank you for contributing a recipe to Margarita Week!
Love this recipe from you and love that you used pink peppercorns! I made an ice cream last year with strawberries and pink peppercorns and I love that extra punch from the spicyness 🙂
Thank you Amisha!! I love your site so much and I’m thrilled you are joining us for Margarita Week! I can’t wait to make your cookie bars, they look so delicious! Hibiscus is one of my all time favorite flavors.
This is just beautiful, Kate! I’ve never had a drink like this before with pink peppercorns, but I bet is tastes lovely with the strawberries! Thank you for hosting Margarita Week 🙂 So many awesome recipes; it’s hard to know where to start!
Thank you so much Dawn!! I love your divine strawberry marg too!! Those might be a little too easy to drink. 🙂
I MUST look for that Powell & Mahoney Margarita Mix, because you are the second person to say it’s good! And I KNOW you have great taste! 😉 This margarita is just gorgeous, Kate! I’m obsessed with the color AND the flavor! Adding the pink peppercorns is GENIUS! I absolutely MUST try this!! Pinned! Cheers, girlfriend and thank you SO much for putting together #margaritaweek! <3
Thanks so much Cheyanne!! Yes, you have to hunt down Powell & Mahoney, it is really delicious!!